It’s not every day that you walk into a performance with such high expectations, but “The Simon & Garfunkel Story,” produced by Impresario Dean Elliott for Maple Tree, left me with no choice. With a track record that includes the lead in “Buddy” and many more, I knew I was in for something special even before I set foot in London’s prestigious Palladium.
This show has earned its stripes as a UK hit in regional theatres, across Europe, and around the world, leaving me with a burning question: What makes it so incredibly successful? My determination to find the answer only added to my anticipation.
Stepping into the Palladium’s auditorium, I was immediately greeted by a tastefully lit stage adorned with a fabulous backdrop and the now-infamous Simon & Garfunkel story logo, setting the stage perfectly for tonight’s performance..
As the two actor-singers graced the stage alongside their backing band, a buzz of anticipation filled the stage and animated into the audience. After all, they were performing at the London Palladium, a career highlight for even the biggest artists in the world.
The show’s tagline, ‘For Once you Can Believe The Hype,’ perfectly encapsulates the experience.
With hit after hit, the show achieved a perfect balance between narration, imagery from the screen, and dialogues from the two leads. What stood out most was the absence of pretentious attempts to be the original artists. No half-baked accents or speaking in the first person here—this was pure theater at its classiest. The actors donned period-accurate attire, reminiscent of Paul and Art’s outfits throughout their illustrious career. In terms of physicality and voice, the casting was spot on, making it easy to believe you were witnessing Simon & Garfunkel themselves on that iconic Palladium stage.
Both leads sang beautifully, their harmonies pitch-perfect, and their musicianship world-class as they seamlessly journeyed through the duo’s exquisite career. The addition of a fabulous brass section to the main band elevated the experience, filling the auditorium with timeless hits like “Mrs. Robinson,” “A Hazy Shade of Winter,” “Cecilia,” “The Sound of Silence,” “Scarborough Fair,” and many more. The retro-inspired lighting design authentically transported the audience back in time, enhancing the nostalgia.
What truly set this show apart was its well-balanced and expertly written script. It took the audience on a captivating journey rather than overwhelming us with a history lesson. I could go on and on about this performance, but I won’t give away any more spoilers. You simply must experience it for yourself.
The show’s tagline, ‘For Once you Can Believe The Hype,’ perfectly encapsulates the experience. It’s a night that exceeded expectations and lived up to the acclaim. A tribute that doesn’t try to be its inspiration, but rather, pays a classy homage to the legends.
…that unbelievably high register was in abundance and it was clear that this vocal range and attention to Sting’s metering and phrasing was no accident
Now before we start – I am a MASSIVE Sting fan. No, I need to really emphasise this a little more. Like a really MASSIVE Sting fan. So, I would very much like to apologise in advance to ‘Bluejays Productions’ and ‘The Rozzers’ for my critical analysis of their show.
Right, I feel better for that intro…With the stage set fairly minimally, but well laid out, with some nice mood lighting, the very healthy crowd had started to get nicely revved up, even before the band arrived on the stage. It’s high energy music at the end of the day and like myself, the audience were expecting a game of two halves, The Police catalogue in Set 1 and Sting in Set 2. That’s what I wanted anyway.
True to expectation, the band sauntered casually onto the stage and picked up their instruments. There was no theatrical ‘blackout’ and why should there be? This was going to be a ‘gig’ in the true sense of the word. I wasn’t expecting or even wanting it to be any other way. The band are emulating ‘The Police,’ the new wave/ punk crossover power three piece. To be honest, I didn’t know if we’d be standing or seated, either would have suited the occasion. But indeed, the audience were sitting, at least for a while anyway.
We were not disappointed, the band opened straight into Message In A Bottle, an early Police track, transporting me straight back to my youth. My partner (a professional vocalist) turned to me immediately and commented, “He sounds exactly like Sting.”
She wasn’t wrong, that unbelievably high register was in abundance and it was clear that this vocal range and attention to Sting’s metering and phrasing was no accident, but a life long study of the man himself. Never wanting to quash dreams or discourage anybody to do what they love. But if anybody out there is thinking of paying tribute to Sting, they would have to really do their homework to come anywhere near the level of Owen James. Not just in his vocal ability, physical presence or on stage persona, but his exceptional bass playing too, with his thumb technique, staying true to that of Sting’s also.
…it was clear that this vocal range and attention to Sting’s metering and phrasing was no accident, but a life long study of the man himself.
Now I’ve gushed over our leading man, lets move onto the rest of the band, starting with the drummer, Dave – Emulating the talents of such ‘high priests’ as Stewart Copeland, Omar Hakim and Vinnie Coliauta is no mean feet, but executed fabulously. I particularly like the attention to detail of the Tama drums, a nod to early Copeland.
The guitarist, Phil, was a bit of a dark horse to say the least. At first, the new wave/ punk songs of early Police only called for some very nifty rhythm playing, something that many guitarists fail to accomplish, often opting for the glory of complex lead solos. But oh no, this was a very accomplished professional, who had Andy Summers and Dominic Miller’s signature production techniques and tones off to a tee as well as being an outstanding rhythm player. Both Summers and Miller were ‘first call’ session players before filling their prospective roles, well versed and extremely proficient in any music situation, again, no mean feet to emulate, but done so superbly.
Although The Police were known for being a there piece unit, their studio recordings often featured keyboards, so from the ‘get go’ we were treated to onstage keyboard player/ vocalist, Alan, who did a splendid job, not only playing the multiple keyboard parts, but really nailing the sounds of the original recordings. His backing vocals were impressive also. Personally, I would have probably opted to keep the keys ‘off-stage’ in the first half to really give the vibe of ‘The Police’ performing in a late 70s/ early 80s Punk/ New Wave club such as CBGBs. That being said, the first half was laden with all the hits and the energy.
Into Set 2, and as expected, it was all about Sting’s solo career and straight into arguably Sting’s finest album, certainly, commercially his most successful, Ten Summoner’s Tales.’ Personally, I don’t envy the job of putting the set list together to try to please everybody. I would have been quite happy to sit there until 2am listening to the songs that I personally wanted to hear, but really this type of show is 2 x 60 minute sets at most and all the most famous singles were covered off from the 15 solo, studio albums released. ‘Fragile’ being a personal highlight for me.
The audience, up on their feet for much of the latter part of the set, were treated to more Police hits towards the end and as an encore, concluding the fabulous evening’s performance with the iconic ‘Roxanne.’
As I said previously, this is not a theatre show in the traditional sense of the word, but most definitely a gig. None the less, I would very much urge any Police/ Sting fans to make a B-line to the ticket page and look for dates. This really is an outstanding tribute to The Police and Sting…I’ll be going again, that’s for sure.
We see a lot of shows. Some good, some bad and some downright awful. But every so often, one comes along that’s very different to the others.
While sitting in the front row of the glorious Stables in Wavendon, I knew that I was witnessing something away from the norm. Was it the style of music? Was the production groundbreaking in anyway? It certainly was a fabulous collection of songs from the sub genre of what we now know as Americana. with nine fabulously talented musicians and singers at the very top of their game, belting out some of the greatest songs ever written. But no, it was something more than that, it was something else – Suddenly, it hit me – It was how refreshingly real and honest this was.
From the absolutely solid foundation of none other than legendary British Rock Legends’ Thunder’s rhythm section, Harry James & Chris Childs, joined by a stalwart of the West End Show scene, MD/ Keys Andy Hartley. On Guitar, none other than James Cassidy, yes, he of Suzi Quattro/ Wishbone Ash fame.
As if that wasn’t enough, on saxophone/ percussion and rhythm guitar we had Tony Rico, who I have to say, was one of the highlights of the night for me – A multi-instrumentalist, playing all instruments to a World Class level with more energy than most young up and coming bands I’ve seen. Not forgetting the beautiful young ladies making up the backing vocal section, with well crafted and very tight vocal arrangements and dance moves. Heading up the band on lead vocals and guitar was household name Ben Mills, the man with the golden voice, and semi finalist from The X-Factor.
Suddenly, it hit me – It was how refreshingly real and honest this was.
With a songlist, featuring hits from Traveling Wilburys, Creedence Clearwater Revival, Bruce Hornsby, The Eagles, The Doobie Brothers and many more, this was surely the soundtrack of many of our lives? The evening flowed beautifully, with Ben and the guys forming a fabulous rapport with the audience in the sold out auditorium. Culminating in at least three encores with the audience up on their feet singing and dancing for the latter half of Act 2.
I was told in the foyer that this was a recent production, in its infancy. If this is the case, I can’t wait to track the progress of this show and offer my sincere praise to the producers and the whole company for an outstanding evening of entertainment.
This is a great show for all fans of the genre, which I wholeheartedly recommend.
As the small but enthusiastic audience started to fill the auditorium, I could certainly sense more than a little excitement. Some dressed in ‘Travoltaesque’ white suits, some as Abba and others in star shaped sunglasses and feather boas, we were in for a lively night.
As the sizeable band hit us with the opening bars of ‘Get Down tonight,’ the KC & The Sunshine Band classic, the crowd instantly rose to their feet and began dancing. If you can’t beat them join them, I remember thinking.
I’d never seen anything quite like this before at a theatre. Usually, particularly with a Home Counties crowd, they need a fair bit of warming up before you’d even get so much of a clap out of them. But I forgot, this was Disco, this was different, the audience had come to dance and dance they did (so did I.)
All the hits were here…That’s The Way, Young Hearts, Blame It On The Boogie, Stayin’ Alive, so many, the first half, ending with the Chic classic, Le Freak.
At the bar, patrons exchanged very favourable reviews of Act 1and were clearly ready to go back and party. As the curtain lifted on Act 2, it was clear the tempo had raised and we were all on a journey to planet glitter ball. Notable favourite’s such as Funky Town, Boogie Oogie Oogie, Play That Funky Music, Car Wash and so many more ending with Disco Inferno.
it was clear the tempo had raised and we were all on a journey to planet glitter ball
The rapturous crowd begged the hard working band for an Encore, and were treated to fabulous renditions of We Are Family and Everybody Dance. Notable performances from the cast were the main man himself, Uncle Funk, who delivered a fabulous performance, aided by the equally wonderful Lauren Mugridge on lead vocals. The vocal and acrobatic talents of The Seifert Sisters for an unaccepted but very welcome addition to the night as were the very talented musicians in support.
In conclusion, a fantastic night, full of fun and energy. If you want a show just to sit quietly and enjoy the music, I would suggest another show. If on the other hand you like to let your hair down and with fellow likeminded partygoers, I cannot recommend this show highly enough.